By Contributing Columnist Victoria Wilde aka Victoria Wilde

There are some traps that every online seller will fall into, and must fall into, to truly learn their lesson and avoid it in the future. Offering free priority shipping and realizing that it eats up all of your profits? Been there, done that. Realizing that magnets don’t work through a layer of modpodge like you thought they would? Yes, thank you. But there’s one lesson that I think is both hard to avoid, yet crucial when starting out a business.
Everyone on Etsy and other online shops knows how important return customers are. For some they are the lifeblood of their shop. It’s why people are putting extra effort into their packaging by putting in personalized thank you cards, wrapping things with tissue paper and special boxes just to go the extra mile. It makes their customers smile and think fondly on their purchase beyond the actual item they bought. So here are a few tips to help you get past the pitfalls of ‘made to order’ and ensure that you can start making repeat customers with your first order, rather than your fiftieth:
1) Never list something that you don’t have the supplies for.
2) Don’t offer too many options
3) Likewise, be SPECIFIC with your options
When a person buys something in the store they get it right away. There’s nothing like that online. Buying online, wonderful as it is, is not an instant satisfaction market, and let’s face it, a LOT of things sold on Etsy, and other Indie shops, are ‘impulse buys’. They’re not necessary for living, they’re things that pretty much everyone can survive without.
It’s YOUR job to make the purchase an experience, and waiting for something that a person paid money for is not a good experience at all. You want to speed up the process of shipping as much as humanly possible. I recently purchased something and it took ages to get here when it should have taken much less time; and this was in the holiday rush season, so it’s understandable why it was late, but even as a seller, knowing how shipping works, I still feel somehow gypped because I didn’t get the item for nearly two weeks later than I should have gotten it. Your customers? It’s a safe bet most people don’t know much about how long shipping takes or much about the postal system. They will not be as understanding and will feel even MORE gypped if there are any delays.
Even if it’s something you can go down to Joannes and get, get it before you list it and make sure you have ENOUGH of the item to make however many you need for your listing. If you have to wait a week and a half for Joannes to stock it, then you have to make it and ship it, that’s an extra 3 weeks before that person gets their item, IF it gets shipped priority mail. If not, then it’s a whole month or more. It’s not a good impression for your business to leave on a customer, and there’s nothing worse than having to say ‘Well sorry, I have to wait to get supplies even though you’ve already paid for the item.’
Don’t offer too many options.
It seems like the more options there are, the more something can get messed up. Say you’re custom making mugs with people’s names on them. You can offer a choice for color and the font of the name. Two or three customizable features are great. But when you start offering different types of cups with different types of handles, fonts, extra sunflower doodles, etchings, textures, combination glazes, it all gets a little crazy. It can also intimidate a buyer who might not really know what they want, and being presented with 50 different things to specify is a little daunting. Even at Starbucks you only have so many options.
If a person really wants a special order with a bunch of specific stuff, then they’ll send you a convo; or better yet you’ll have your Alchemy set up to receive such specific requests.
Likewise, be SPECIFIC which options you offer.
While we’re talking about mugs, a while ago I bought something for a friend of mine, with her name on a mug. Now, the picture had a kind of ‘Times/Capital’ font, and I thought it looked great. When I got the mug, I was a little disappointed to find out that the font was actually something very different. She still loved the mug and I left positive feedback because it was beautiful- BUT- the example of the mug was not specific, and nowhere in the listing for the customizable mug did it say anything about different fonts.
Even if it seems trivial to you, make sure that you write it in somewhere. Say ‘the ribbon will be a random color’ or ‘you may not get this exact tag/stamp pattern/paper’ if it’s something that you do randomly or is out of your control. Your buyer can’t feel, pick up or see the actual item in person they’re purchasing, and buying things handmade often feels like a gamble; you never know if you’re going to get a truly honest buyer or someone making shoddy items and just trying to swindle people out of their money. Do everything you can to convince your customer that you’re the real McCoy, it’s a quality item, and that they will KNOW exactly what they are getting.